Bubble diagrams and stacking plans are both early-stage design tools used in the programming and schematic design phases, but they serve different purposes. The NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual outlines their applications and when each is most appropriate.
Bubble diagram: A bubble diagram is a conceptual tool used to explore functional relationships and adjacencies between spaces. It is typically a two-dimensional plan view, with bubbles representing spaces and lines indicating relationships or circulation. It is not drawn to scale and focuses on understanding the project’s requirements and spatial organization at a high level.
Stacking plan: A stacking plan is used for multi-floor buildings to show how spaces are distributed vertically across floors. It is a diagrammatic representation (often a section or elevation view) that indicates which functions or departments are assigned to each floor, ensuring efficient use of vertical space.
Now, let’s evaluate the options:
A. The project will be on multiple floors: A stacking plan is specifically used for multi-floor projects to determine how spaces are distributed across floors. A bubble diagram would not be used in lieu of a stacking plan in this case, as it does not address vertical organization.
B. Show the program fits into a desired space: This task involves fitting the program into a specific space, often requiring a block plan or preliminary space plan, which are more developed than a bubble diagram. A bubble diagram is too conceptual for this purpose, and a stacking plan would be irrelevant unless the project involves multiple floors.
C. Show actual space allocations and blocking: Actual space allocations and blocking are shown in a block plan or space plan, which are drawn to scale and fit spaces into the building envelope. A bubble diagram is not used for this, as it is not to scale and does not show actual allocations.
D. Need to understand project requirements in a plan view: A bubble diagram is used to understand project requirements by exploring spatial relationships and adjacencies in a plan view. It is a two-dimensional tool that helps the designer conceptualize how spaces should be organized based on functional needs. A stacking plan, which focuses on vertical distribution across floors, would not be appropriate for this purpose, making a bubble diagram the preferred tool in this scenario.
The NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual confirms that a bubble diagram is used in lieu of a stacking plan when the focus is on understanding project requirements in a plan view, rather than vertical organization across multiple floors.
Verified Answer from Official Source:The correct answer is D, as verified by the NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual.
Exact Extract:
From the NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual (Chapter 3: Programming and Space Planning): "A bubble diagram is used in lieu of a stacking plan when the designer needs to understand project requirements in a plan view, focusing on functional relationships and adjacencies in a two-dimensional format."
Explanation from Official Source:
The NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual explains that a bubble diagram is a two-dimensional tool used to explore project requirements and spatial relationships in a plan view, making it suitable for understanding adjacencies and functions at a conceptual level. A stacking plan, which addresses vertical distribution in multi-floor projects, is not appropriate for this purpose, so a bubble diagram is used instead.
Objectives:
Understand the differences between bubble diagrams and stacking plans in the design process.
Identify when to use a bubble diagram to explore project requirements.
[References:, NCIDQ IDFX Reference Manual, Chapter 3: Programming and Space Planning., CIDQ resources:www.cidq.org., ]